news
Washington — Why Cosmetics Don't Need Safety Testing Before Sale

A PBS report examines why cosmetics sold in the United States can reach store shelves without any government safety testing, a gap rooted in federal law rather than a regulatory oversight, according to the PBS story.
What does federal law actually require for cosmetics?
The core rule dates to the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act, signed in 1938, which gives the FDA authority to pull an unsafe cosmetic off shelves after the fact but does not require a manufacturer to prove safety before selling it. That 1938 framework is the baseline PBS points to when explaining why a lipstick or lotion can launch nationwide without an FDA safety review.
How is that different from drugs?
A prescription or over-the-counter drug cannot be sold until the FDA reviews clinical data and approves it. Cosmetics skip that step entirely under the same 1938 law. The distinction matters because many skincare products marketed with active ingredients sit in a gray zone; shoppers comparing a retinoid serum to a drug-grade retinoid should note that only the drug version went through FDA approval, a line explained in Rey's Refined Radiance's retinol-versus-retinal breakdown.
What changed with the 2022 reform law?
Congress passed the Modernization of Cosmetics Regulation Act, signed into law in December 2022, the first major update to cosmetics oversight since 1938. MoCRA added facility registration and adverse-event reporting duties for manufacturers. It did not add a requirement for pre-market safety testing, which is the gap PBS's report centers on 84 years after the original statute and still four years after the newest reform.
The two dates that frame the gap
- 1938: The FD&C Act establishes FDA oversight of cosmetics but sets no pre-market testing requirement.
- 2022: MoCRA adds registration and reporting rules but leaves the testing requirement unchanged.
What can a consumer check before buying?
Ingredient labels are the main public record available, since no federal testing certificate exists for most cosmetics. Shoppers can cross-reference active ingredients against general skincare guidance, such as Rey's Refined Radiance's science-backed routine tips, which walk through how to evaluate formulas layer by layer.
What to watch
- Whether FDA issues new guidance tied to MoCRA's adverse-event reporting requirement.
- Whether lawmakers revisit pre-market testing authority in future legislation.
- Whether individual states add testing or disclosure rules beyond the federal floor.
- Whether manufacturers voluntarily publish third-party safety data as a marketing differentiator.
Artiglio is A coming-soon iPhone chief of staff for briefings and drafts. Not on the App Store yet.
Questions
Does the FDA approve cosmetics before they go on sale?
No. Under the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act of 1938, the FDA can act against an unsafe cosmetic after it reaches the market but does not require pre-market safety testing or approval.
Did the 2022 MoCRA law require cosmetics safety testing?
No. The Modernization of Cosmetics Regulation Act, signed in December 2022, added facility registration and adverse-event reporting requirements but did not create a pre-market safety testing mandate.